The Lombard Review

Japan raised rates. The yen fell anyway

Carry dominates signalling

View of Chuo-dori, southwards from Nihonbashi
View of Chuo-dori, southwards from Nihonbashi Photo: Sitao Xiang/Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

Key dataUSDJPY ~151

The Bank of Japan delivered its first interest rate increase in seventeen years, yet the immediate market response was a counterintuitive slide in the domestic currency. The yen weakened past 151 per dollar, brushing multi-decade lows. Foreign exchange markets offered a masterclass in separating symbolic policy milestones from prevailing carry dynamics.

A small local currency exchange office, that is located in the North-Brabander city of Tilburg, Meierij van 's-Hertogenbosch
A small local currency exchange office, that is located in the North-Brabander city of Tilburg, Meierij van 's-Hertogenbosch Photo: Unknown/Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

The Unforgiving Carry Spread

Even with the BoJ lifting rates above zero, the interest rate differential between the United States (5.3 per cent) and Japan (0.1 per cent) remains an enormous chasm exceeding 500 basis points. Because Kazuo Ueda committed to keeping monetary conditions broadly accommodative, the incentive for institutional capital to borrow yen and harvest yield overseas remains completely intact. Rate hikes without tightening do not defend a currency.

Pumpjack east of Andrews, TX
Pumpjack east of Andrews, TX Photo: Zorin09/Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 3.0

The yen’s post-hike slide demonstrates that symbolic rate increases cannot defeat a 500-basis-point carry spread; carry will continue to crush the currency until Tokyo closes the yield gap.

Write to The Lombard Review at contact@thelombardreview.com

More From The Lombard Review